What's Available Now from SFSmedia?
SFSmedia is now releasing Keeping Score titles in HDVD:
-
Berlioz Symphonie Fantastique. Michael Tilson Thomas
directs the San Francisco Symphony in a recent performance of Symphonie Fantastique as
part of the "Keeping Score" universal outreach program of the San Francisco Symphony. In
addition, Thomas narrates a 55-minute Public Television educational program about Berlioz
and the Symphonie Fantastique. SFSmedia is shooting here for a state-of-the-art
product, alpha to omega. Released in 2009, this disc is 99.5% in high-definition video
and has TrueHD 7.1 sound.
It seems no vendor in Europe has this title directly now, but you can place an import order
by clicking on Symphonie Fantastique.
It is available now from Amazon in these countries:
USA,
UK, or
Canada.
 
[Although I always loved Harold in Italy, I hated all other music by Berlioz,
including Symphony fantastique. Would watching the Keeping Score documentary
about Symphony fantastique make a difference? Michael Tilson Thomas is almost
as good a speaker and teacher as he is a conductor. The documentary was made, I think,
to show on public television. It has all the production values you would expect like
gorgeous shots of Paris and other locations in France and Italy, excellent writing
based on careful research, and expert movie making. Thomas tells about the life of Berlioz,
and he makes the Symphony fantastique come alive as he explains the themes
and aspects of the music in relation to the dramatic loves of young Hector.
I then listened 3 times to the live performance of Symphony fantastique by
the San Francisco Symphony.
On first listening I was surprised to discover that I didn't hate the symphony
any more---so the documentary was working. On second listening I began to wonder,
"Is this the best recording of a symphony that I have experienced?" Shaking my head,
I starting looking around for a comparison. Why, we already have another recording of
Symphony fantastique in HDVD---the one by Ozawa and the Saito Kinen Orchestra published by NHK!
So for my third listening I did many movement-by-movement comparisons of the
Thomas and Ozawa versions. According to Gramophone magazine, the San Francisco Symphony
is the 13th best in the world, and the Saito Kinen ranks 19th. But surely you wouldn't
expect any festival orchestra to be competitive with the likes of the San Francisco
band when they are recording in their own lair (Davies Hall) with its state-of-the art
recording facilities. Well, the Saito Kinen group is competitive, and I now have even
more respect for their singular accomplishments than before. But the comparison
also bolstered my feeling that the Thomas recording could indeed be a
reference recording for a symphony.
Seeing the musicians perform in HDVD makes what you hear more impressive than
merely listening to the music, say, from a CD. The video record of the San Francisco
Symphony performance of Symphony fantastique is probably as good as could be
expected with today's technology. The light was bright enough to allow high
resolution camera work, but also warm enough to avoid eye-strain and give everybody
and everything a healthy glow. The stage is equipped with the normal long range
cameras plus special cameras that move about by remote control within the orchestra.
There is a command center for the video work that was invented by Dr. Strangelove.
It gives the TV director (Gary Halvorson, I think) the ability to plan and make
many different short close-ups of the musicians in rapid succession throughout the show.
So while Thomas is frantically conducting the mass of players before him,
Strangelove is engaged in even more frantic (if unseen) efforts to follow the score
and the music in making his movie of the performance. The players know this.
No longer can a player hide. At any time, and especially when musical ball is
passed to him, anybody can become the star! This must be an exciting and intimidating
new aspect of working as as classical musician.
Although the mikes are almost invisible, the quality of this recording proves
that Davies Hall is also extraordinarily well equipped to record the sounds of the musicians.
So now put it all together. As is pointed out in one of the extras features on
this disc, when the video shows, say, the concertmaster, his violin is what
the viewer hears. Because the TV director in Davies Hall has such extraordinary
control over both the aural and visual material coming from the musicians,
the TV director becomes a kind of second conductor! Thomas is the conductor
from the perspective of the players and the live audience. What Thomas brings
forth is what the people in Davies Hall experience. But Strangelove determines
what we in our home theater will experience, and he may contribute as much to
our great experience as Thomas does.
In this recording, the experience we get is fine indeed. The basis for all,
of course, is Thomas's masterly knowledge of the piece (conducted without a score) and
his ability to lead his talented troupe where they need to go. Still, Ozawa is probably
every bit as good at this as any other conductor. Thomas also has the advantage
of leading an ensemble that has played together for years, and now they are in their home court.
Probably the audience in Davies Hall heard a stronger performance than the
audience at the Saito Kinen festival. But would you tell much difference in these
performances if all you had was a recording of each from an identical
single camera and single mike? I think probably not.
The difference between a great recording and an reference recording comes
from the quality of the gear and the skill of staff placed under the control of Strangelove.
Because of the closeness of the video and aural recordings made at Davies hall,
we feel we are even closer to the musicians than Thomas is. We are struck by
the wide dynamic range we hear (and even see) as Thomas quickly moves from soft
to loud and back. As we hear the musical lead pass from player to player and
section to section, we are simultaneously transported visually as well as aurally
around the stage. And finally, we are treated to a astonishing degree of detail.
For example, when the harps come in during the "Un Bal" movement, we see and hear
them with a brilliance that is startling. We hear even the smallest tap-crash from
the cymbals because, just for a fraction of a second, we see them touch. When
Jeffrey Anderson proclaims the Dies Irae on his tuba, we know from his expression
that something terrible is afoot.
This thumbnail is getting too long, so I will end my description of how "Keeping Score"
changed me from a hater to lover of Symphony fantastique. But I should also
say that I have only touched on other important aspects of the "Keeping Score" outreach
program of the San Francisco Symphony. I look forward to viewing other HDVD titles
from Thomas and forces. Henry McFadyen, Jr.]
 
-
Charles Ives Holidays Symphony. Michael Tilson Thomas
directs the San Francisco Symphony in a recent performance of the Holidays Symphony as
part of the "Keeping Score" universal outreach program of the San Francisco Symphony. In
addition, Thomas narrates an educational program about Ives
and the Holidays Symphony.
It is available now from Amazon in these countries:
USA,
UK, or
Canada.
 
[Please let us know if you would like
to write a thumbnail description here about this title.]
 
-
Shostakovich Symphony No. 5. Michael Tilson Thomas
directs the San Francisco Symphony in a recent performance of the Shostakovich
Symphony No. 5 as part of the "Keeping Score" universal outreach program of the
San Francisco Symphony. In addition, Thomas narrates an educational program
about Shostakovich and the Symphony No. 5. SFSmedia is shooting here for a state-of-the-art
product, alpha to omega. Released in 2009, this disc is high-definition video
and has TrueHD 5.1 sound.
It is available now from Amazon in these countries:
USA,
UK, or
Canada.
 
[Please let us know if you would like
to write a thumbnail description here about this title.]